The Louis Zimmerman House, 1877 Historic home in Zoar, Ohio - $450k

The Louis Zimmerman Home for sale in Zoar, Ohio. Built in 1877, former residence of the Zoar Society Treasurer, three-course red brick exterior, original white oak tongue-and-groove flooring with square nails, historic 18x32 Wash House with embedded cast iron wash tubs, heated 2005 Carriage House with 3 car bays, corner lot, 3 bedrooms, 2528 square feet. $450,000.

The Louis Zimmerman House 1877 Zoar Ohio 2

House overview

Step back in time with the Louis Zimmerman House, a masterfully preserved 1877 residence situated on a prominent corner lot in the heart of the Historic District of Zoar Village.

Once the home of the Treasurer of the Zoar Society, this remarkable property is proudly listed on the National Register of Historic Places and recognized by the Tuscarawas Heritage Home Association. It offers a rare opportunity to own a significant piece of communal utopian history in rural Northeast Ohio.

Architectural integrity and interior highlights

The home stands on its original, robust sandstone foundation, featuring a timeless red-brick exterior constructed with a durable three-course layout. Inside, the 2,528-square-foot floor plan boasts 7 rooms, including 3 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, a welcoming formal foyer, and two expansive hallways.

Original historic character shines throughout the home, anchored by gorgeous white oak tongue-and-groove flooring secured with authentic square nails.
The inviting family room features a cozy Jotul wood-burning stove backed by a newly replaced brick chimney.
A full, unfinished third-floor attic offers excellent storage or restoration potential, complete with matching white oak tongue-and-groove floors under a meticulously maintained original slate roof.

To sweeten the historic charm, all window treatments, hand-painted canvas floor mats, and floor rugs are included with the property, alongside select genuine Zoar artifacts and furniture pieces that will convey with the sale.

Exceptional subterranean and outdoor living

The lower levels and grounds of this property are just as spectacular as the main living quarters.

The Wine Cellar: A true showstopper, the fully decorated, furnished, and vaulted 16’ x 20’ wine cellar provides an unmatched atmosphere for hosting and tastings.
The Grounds: The yard is completely enclosed by a weathered, authentic Zoar-style wood fence. Outdoor relaxation is effortless with two distinct front porches, a rear porch, a private brick patio for entertaining, and matching brick walkways and driveway.

Historic outbuildings and modern carriage house

The property features two incredible secondary structures that bridge the gap between 19th-century history and modern convenience:

The Original Wash House (18’ x 32’): Located at the rear of the home, this pristine historic outbuilding features three separate rooms: the original laundry room where the Zoarites washed clothes - complete with cast iron wash tubs embedded in a brick fireplace - an authentic workshop with an original workbench, and a historic "his and hers" privy.

The Heated Carriage House (Built 2005): Thoughtfully constructed to blend seamlessly with the village’s historic aesthetic, this newer building incorporates original historic Zoar windows salvaged from another local home. It offers three deep garage bays, a dedicated workshop area, and extensive second-floor storage.

Modern mechanicals and updates

While the home retains its 19th-century soul, it functions with 21st-century efficiency:

Dual-zone HVAC (Gas heat and central air conditioning powered by two modern units).
Updated 200 AMP electrical service.
Durable copper plumbing.
Premium stainless steel spouting/gutters added within the last 5 years.
Separate outside walk-out entrance to the utility side of the basement.

Community and location

Nestled in a picturesque, rural historic village, Zoar offers a quiet, community-oriented lifestyle with the convenience of larger commercial hubs located just 30 minutes in any direction. Whether you are an old house purist or looking for a unique historic property with modern amenities, the Louis Zimmerman house is a true Ohio landmark.

Showings by appointment only.

House details

Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 1.5
Interior area: 2,528 sqft
Lot size: 0.36 Acres
Year built: 1887
Style: Single-Family
State: Ohio
Price: $450,000
Photos and info: McDowell Real Estate and Owner
Contact: Kylie Graska, McDowell Real Estate on Your HomeCourt Team
- Tel: (330) 418-1841
- Email: Kyliegraska@mcdhomes.com
Address: 214 Main St, Zoar, OH 44697